← Back to the repository
Journal ArticleOpen Access

Ջեմալ փաշայի ցեղասպան քաղաքականության արդարացման փորձերը թուրք պատմաբանների կողմից (Attempts by Turkish Historians to Justify Cemal Pasha's Genocidal Policy)

Anumyan, Meline · 2025

Anumyan takes up a thesis recently circulated by some Turkish historians: that Cemal Pasha, Ottoman Minister of the Navy during the Genocide, was more tolerant toward Armenians than the other Young Turk leaders and opposed the deportations. She isolates four principal propositions supporting that narrative and refutes each in turn. Her conclusion is that although Cemal's stance appears at first glance to differ from that of the other perpetrators, it was in substance identical: his goal too was the elimination of the Armenians as a nation, pursued primarily through assimilation. She argues the rehabilitation of principal architects of the Genocide is dangerous precisely because it can install a groundless image of the 'Armenophile Turk' in Armenian public consciousness.

Read the publication ↗
Published in
Պատմություն և մշակույթ / History and Culture, Vol. 22, No. 1, pp. 103–109 (Yerevan State University); DOI 10.46991/hc.2025.22.1.103
Year
2025
Language
Armenian
DOI
10.46991/hc.2025.22.1.103

Citation

Anumyan, Meline 2025. Ջեմալ փաշայի ցեղասպան քաղաքականության արդարացման փորձերը թուրք պատմաբանների կողմից (Attempts by Turkish Historians to Justify Cemal Pasha's Genocidal Policy). Պատմություն և մշակույթ / History and Culture, Vol. 22, No. 1, pp. 103–109 (Yerevan State University); DOI 10.46991/hc.2025.22.1.103. https://doi.org/10.46991/hc.2025.22.1.103

What this offers a reader

For students

A clean, short takedown of a revisionist claim you will meet sooner or later.

For academics

Denial-critique by a specialist in Turkish-language sources; Armenian-language with English abstract.

For the community

There was no good Young Turk. This shows why the story that there was, is being told.

For a general reader

Was one of the Young Turk leaders secretly a friend to Armenians? No.

Topics

Armenian Genocidedenial and revisionismCemal PashaYoung Turksforced assimilationTurkish historiography

Related in the repository

Armenian Genocide Survivor Oral History as an Archival Resource
2025 · Journal Article
Formulation and Use of the Concept of "Resistance" in the Context of Genocides
2025 · Journal Article
Rasulain and the Arada Steppe During the Armenian Genocide, July 1915 – April 1916
2025 · Journal Article
Religion and Spirituality in the Memoirs of Child Survivors of the Armenian Genocide
2025 · Journal Article

Citation checked against the publisher's record on .